Nature of Jobseeker’s Agreement; actively seeking employment; burden of proof - Kerr v Department of Social Development [2004] UKHL 23
3 posters
BenefitsAdvice :: Daily impact :: LAW
Page 1 of 1
helping_hand- Posts : 163
Points : 354
Reputation : 79
Join date : 2017-07-10
Re: Nature of Jobseeker’s Agreement; actively seeking employment; burden of proof - Kerr v Department of Social Development [2004] UKHL 23
(d)The F-tT misunderstood the requirements of actively seeking employment. He asserts that it was not necessary for him to provide information
or
produce evidence about what he had done to fulfil this requirement.
Answer:
The F-tT did not misunderstand the law in any material way.
It was up to the appellant to show that he was actively seeking employment by providing information about his jobseeking activities.
(e)
The F-tT erred in law by placing a burden of proof on him to show he was actively seeking employment.
Answer: At the end of the day, the appellant failed to provide evidence peculiarly within his own knowledge that was needed to establish continuing entitlement.
Accordingly, if there was any doubt about his entitlement, it was rightly decided against his interest.
or
produce evidence about what he had done to fulfil this requirement.
Answer:
The F-tT did not misunderstand the law in any material way.
It was up to the appellant to show that he was actively seeking employment by providing information about his jobseeking activities.
(e)
The F-tT erred in law by placing a burden of proof on him to show he was actively seeking employment.
Answer: At the end of the day, the appellant failed to provide evidence peculiarly within his own knowledge that was needed to establish continuing entitlement.
Accordingly, if there was any doubt about his entitlement, it was rightly decided against his interest.
Re: Nature of Jobseeker’s Agreement; actively seeking employment; burden of proof - Kerr v Department of Social Development [2004] UKHL 23
So, fundamentally, we are at the whim of what the DWP think is reasonable (!!) proof of being ASE.
Even while JSA is phased out I can see no respite...
Brutus- Posts : 394
Points : 504
Reputation : 106
Join date : 2017-04-15
Location : Southwark, South East London
Similar topics
» Variation of Jobseeker's Agreement – failure to comply with a direction – termination of Jobseeker's Agreement – reasonableness of direction
» Universal Jobmatch amongst other things - Variation of Jobseeker's Agreement | PG –v- SSWP (JSA) [2017] UKUT 388 (AAC)
» ACTIVELY SEEKING WORK
» Top tips - JSA Actively Seeking / other conditionality doubts & decisions
» Dispute over contents of revised jobseeker’s agreement
» Universal Jobmatch amongst other things - Variation of Jobseeker's Agreement | PG –v- SSWP (JSA) [2017] UKUT 388 (AAC)
» ACTIVELY SEEKING WORK
» Top tips - JSA Actively Seeking / other conditionality doubts & decisions
» Dispute over contents of revised jobseeker’s agreement
BenefitsAdvice :: Daily impact :: LAW
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum